You can't fool us, Bernard

Dick Best13 April 2012

Does France coach Bernard Laporte actually think that we believe his latest stance on foul play? His holier-than-thou attitude is a joke.

Laporte is another in a very long line of French coaches who have jumped on that bandwagon and believe the rest of the rugby world will fall for it.

It does not occur to them that we have heard it all before: how these hardline disciplinarian French coaches are going to stamp out violence in their domestic and national teams.

You only have to look at the opening game in this Six Nations Championship to see that once French players cross the white line they are on their own - and no matter how much ranting and raving Laporte does in press conferences, training sessions and dressing rooms, French players just cannot stop themselves from committing acts of foul play.

In the Italy game - France's first of the Championship and a chance to create the right impression and image - their brilliant captain Olivier Magne was cited by the match commissioner for treading on an Italian player's head.

He's supposed to be the coach's right-hand man.

Lock David Auradou spent 10 minutes in the sin-bin for raking an Italian player's back with no earthly chance of winning the ball.

Remember - this was their first game. What a joke!

Laporte then had the audacity to discipline the lock by not playing him against Wales a fortnight later, and told anyone who was listening that France were stamping out violence. Interestingly, both Magne and Auradou magically reappear in French colours on Saturday against England, having missed the Welsh game. Big deal.

What a sacrifice it is to miss a game against Wales these days.

France have felt quite strongly that over the past decade there has been a conspiracy against their players by other countries' referees, and that is why they have had more players sent off than any other northern hemisphere team.

This procession of French players to the dressing rooms for an early bath does not just stop at international level. Statistics in the European club competitions - the Heineken Cup and the Parker Pen Shield - also show that more French clubs have had players sent off than any other nation.

Perhaps the conspiracy theory can be stretched down another level?

There is no doubt there is a fine line between hard, physical play and violence in a contact sport.

Kicking, punching and headbutting, which form the basis of sending-off offences in rugby union, have no place in the sport.

But in French club matches they are still very much in evidence - even though the game has been professional for seven years.

So why has Laporte stood up and protested until he's blue in the face that France are cleaning up their act?

Is this some massive con job? That France will send out a team on Saturday whose PR campaign has been all about schoolboy discipline - and then, from the first whistle, climb into England with a ferocity that will put them off their game? The frightening thing about French teams is they contain so much talent and so many good players that if they just got on with the game, they could be ranked No1 in the world instead of England.

This current French team is no different. The backs are very special and if they turn it on, and it's a big if, England will be on the ropes and another Grand Slam might go down the pan.

Maybe all the talk about violence is a diversion. Maybe France will turn it on. Maybe the leopard will change its spots.

Dick Best is a former England Grand Slam-winning coach

Create a FREE account to continue reading

eros

Registration is a free and easy way to support our journalism.

Join our community where you can: comment on stories; sign up to newsletters; enter competitions and access content on our app.

Your email address

Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number

You must be at least 18 years old to create an account

* Required fields

Already have an account? SIGN IN

By clicking Create Account you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use , Cookie policy and Privacy policy .

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in