‘Many hundreds of thousands’ exposed to coronavirus in early March, senior health official says

Testing plans were abandoned in mid-March after a million cases were predicted across the UK, the Government’s testing coordinator said
Widespread testing and contact tracing in the UK was stopped on March 12
PA
Imogen Braddick22 May 2020

Many hundreds of thousands of people had been exposed to coronavirus by the time testing and tracing was stopped in mid-March, a senior health official has said.

Professor Yvonne Doyle, Public Health England's medical director, told the Commons Science and Technology Committee that widespread testing and contact tracing was stopped on March 12 due to the “sheer scale of cases in the UK”.

The Government’s testing coordinator Professor John Newton, who is also PHE’s director of health improvement, said the testing plans were abandoned after a million cases of Covid-19 were predicted across the UK.

He said there had been a discussion in the Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies (Sage) which established that it would “not be worthwhile” to continue contact tracing once community transmission took hold.

UK returns to work as Coronavirus restrictions are eased - In pictures

1/29

The comments contrast with those from Health Secretary Matt Hancock, who has defended leaving care home guidance in place until March 12 that said the risk of infection across care homes was low.

On Tuesday, Mr Hancock told the Commons that community transmission of coronavirus in the UK in early to mid-March was low.

Prof Doyle told MPs the policy decision was to focus on the NHS in terms of testing and that, given the testing resources available, a decision was taken to stop more widespread community testing and tracing.

She said it was stopped in March “because of the sheer scale of cases in the UK, which had been introduced by multiple introductions, particularly after half-term, and from European countries we now know had large amounts of prevalence themselves”.

She added: “So we have multiple introductions, with many hundreds of thousands of people by March who had now been exposed to this virus in this country.

“Contact tracing could not possibly have had the capacity to address that.

“And with the capacity of lab testing and our contact tracers, we felt the most important thing to do was to focus on where there was national concern, which was the capacity of the NHS, to accrue that testing.”

Prof Doyle told MPs the organisation did not reject the South Korean model of mass coronavirus testing, and had in fact followed a similar path until March.

“We did not reject the South Korean model, in fact we were very interested in what was happening internationally from the get-go," she said.

“The testing capacity and testing profile of PHE’s approach in the contain phase – which is between January and March – was very close to the one of South Korea for quite a long time, into early March.”

Prof Newton said the decision in March to abandon testing and tracing was made by Government, not just PHE.

“When in March it became apparent that community transmission was occurring and we had multiple injections, introductions from different countries in the UK, that decision was then enacted,” Prof Newton told MPs.

“It was a decision of course of Government, informed by all its advisers, not just Public Health England.”

Medical Director at Public Health England Professor Yvonne Doyle
PA

He added: “The epidemiology was crucial, we had an increase in the number of cases in March.

“The advice from modellers was that within a short period we would expect to be having a million cases in the UK, and of course if you have a million cases there’s no way, however much contact tracing or testing capacity you have, that you can pursue the South Korea model.

“At that point, the Government made the decision to move to lockdown as the most appropriate response to the epidemiology in the UK at the time.”

Downing Street said the decision to move away from contact tracing in mid-March was taken by the Government’s experts.

Asked if it was a decision by ministers, the Prime Minister’s official spokesman said: “It was set out at the time by the Government experts who were attending the daily press conference why they had reached the decision to start focusing their testing on people who were sick in hospital.

“That’s how I remember the decision making process.”

UK stays alerts during Coronavirus - In pictures

1/29

Prof Newton also told the Science and Technology Select Committee that more than half of the home testing kits sent out had been returned, but he did not have an up-to-date figure.

He added: “I think certainly more than half, and we would like to get that amount up.

“A lot of the ones which were counted as they left were not home tests, they were the satellite tests sent out to care homes.”

When pressed on the current return rate he said he would provide it to the committee after the session.

Prof Newton added: “I am afraid I don’t have that figure but it can be provided.”

Create a FREE account to continue reading

eros

Registration is a free and easy way to support our journalism.

Join our community where you can: comment on stories; sign up to newsletters; enter competitions and access content on our app.

Your email address

Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number

You must be at least 18 years old to create an account

* Required fields

Already have an account? SIGN IN

By clicking Create Account you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use , Cookie policy and Privacy policy .

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in